Yep, she's totally different from #1! This shawl will be very neutral. She will be my "winter" Charlotte. I plan to frog what you see here. I didn't do cable cast on, and so the edge dips down where my first seven sts are. Me no likey, so OUT it's going to go. I don't feel so bad. I frogged Charlotte #1 at oh say row 60 or so. I'm going to make a note on my pattern this time, to help me remember which cast on method to use!